The Flightless Man: Self-Awareness in Fakhr al-Din al-Razi

Abstract

The flying man thought experiment upon which Avicenna grounds his theory of self-awareness (al-shuur al-dhati) and justifies the argument that the soul is an immaterial, incorporeal and independent substance, has drawn as much interest in the modern era as it has in the classical Islamic and Latin worlds, spawning various interpretations on what to make of the experiment's basic claim and purpose. Commentators of both traditions differ on the basic claim and purpose of the flying man experiment, depending the ontological and epistemological attitudes they emphasize. This study firstly tries to clarify the claim and purpose of the experiment, inasmuch as it forms the basis of Fakhr al-Din al-Razi's criticisms. It proceeds to briefly point out the context of the experiment from Avicenna to al-Razi, and examine al-Razi's comments and criticisms thereof. Since he rejects the claim that the soul is an immaterial, incorporeal and independent substance, it follows that al-Razi does not understand the term essence (dhat) in self-awareness (al-shuur al-dhati) in the same way as Avicenna, who through the experiment, argues the exact opposite. Al-Razi rather interprets essence directly as the self, from which he proceeds to develop a distinct understanding of self-awareness.